Skip to content
A Long Game Project lab
Gilded graded 1763 engraving of a riot in the pit of Covent Garden Theatre, marked with tea-stain rings

In 62 of 100 runs of our simulation, the private discounts stayed secret.

Business software is sold one licence per person, and AI agents now do those people’s work. When does the price reset, and who pays?

Report 002 · The Quiet Discount · Dr Dan Epstein · version 0.10 · 12 October 2026
A Strategy Soup Scenario What is an exercised scenario?

TLDR

1Most business software is sold by the licence, one per named person, so the bill follows head count.

2AI agents, software that does a whole job on its own, now do much of that work.

3We ran the next four years as a simulation, then re-ran it a hundred times.

4The incumbent vendor, the big software company in the simulation, kept its published list price and gave discounts in private.

5The AI-native challenger, a smaller rival, published a price comparison five times. No customer would put its name to it.

6In 62 of the hundred re-runs, the private discounts stayed secret to mid-2030. A customer published its real price in only 16.

7Who pays? The incumbent vendor loses a little, and the corporate buyer gains. In the middle re-run, the incumbent vendor’s market-strength score slipped from 100 to 95.

How the simulation works

In the live run, each of the four players chose its own moves and gave its reasons. The live run lasted five half-year turns, to the end of 2028.

Then a version of the simulation with fixed rules replayed all eight half-years, late 2026 to mid-2030, a hundred times. Those are the re-runs.

The story’s last three half-years, 2029 to mid-2030, are written from the re-runs, on dates we chose.

One turnHalf a year. A player names a move. Chance decides whether it works, with odds set by the simulation’s rules.
ScoreEach player’s strength in the market, on a scale we chose. The incumbent vendor starts at 100. Zero means out.
The secretCustomers pay less than the list price, in private.

The real facts stop in August 2026. Everything dated later is the simulation’s story, not a forecast.

The players

The incumbent vendorA very large software company selling licences per person. It wants its list price left alone.
The AI-native challengerA smaller AI rival. It charges only when its software finishes a job, so it needs a public price comparison.
The corporate buyerA big company that buys software. Its finance chief pays for licences nobody logs into.
The integratorA consulting firm paid to install the software, whichever way of charging wins.

What happened

Late 2026The incumbent vendor renamed its product “agent-inclusive”, so the AI agents came inside the licence. It kept the list price and discounted two big customers in private.
2027The corporate buyer counted its unused licences and kept the count private, to bargain with at its own renewal.
2028Trials of AI agents kept failing, so the incumbent vendor argued this renewal was not the time to switch.
2029Our story takes the rarer path: a big customer publishes what it really pays. Later deals start from that number.
2030The incumbent vendor ended close to where it started. No player was driven out.

The numbers

The claim, 2026 to 2030Fig. 1

In 62 of 100 re-runs, the secret was kept to mid-2030: no customer published what it paid, and no buyer called out the rename.

Out of 100 re-runs: secret still kept1009384757469656262 kept38 outH2H1H2H1H2H1H2H120262027202820292030
Secret out: a customer published what it paid, or a buyer called out the incumbent vendor’s renamed product in public.

What it means

The runs did not track prices, only whether the secret came out. Vendor and buyer both wanted it kept private, so other buyers had no real price to compare.

If you buy software, decide on purpose whether to publish what you pay. If you sell licences, watch the customer already leaving you. In our story, it publishes first.

The line

In 62 of 100 runs, the secret was kept to mid-2030.
The incumbent vendor’s score fell from 100 to 95. The corporate buyer’s rose from 70 to 79.

Got it?

READ NORMAL MODE