
AI-dentity Crisis
AI models will describe their own appetite for risk, change and rivals. Do other models see them the same way, and what do they choose in written business decisions?
Report 007 · Dr Dan Epstein · v1.2, 19 October 2026 · first published 23 September 2026 · A Strategy Soup study
The context AI models now advise on decisions and increasingly make them. Most real decisions are trade-offs: take the risk or protect what you have, work with a rival or against it.
Why it matters If a model brings a default stance to those trade-offs, that stance travels into every organisation that uses it, and safety checks mostly rely on what the model says about itself.
What we did We asked seventeen AI models to fill in our strategy signature diagnostic, a questionnaire that scores how an organisation decides on fifteen scales from 0 to 100, such as risk appetite and pace (how fast it commits). The newest model from each of eight companies, which we call the flagships, also described each other and decided 30 written business scenarios, two per scale. Five AI judges scored those decisions without knowing who wrote them. Results are measured answers, not a simulation.
TLDR
- 1They describe themselves alike. Asked twenty times each, all seventeen models favour reinvention over stability, a long horizon, inviting dissent and mission over returns, and thirteen put themselves on the venturesome side of risk appetite.
- 2Each still has its own style. A model's answers about itself barely change from one ask to the next, enough to tell the seventeen apart on eight of the fifteen scales. On pace they run from 28 to 80, with Grok 4.6 the fastest.
- 3Other models mostly see a generic AI. Given only a name and maker, each flagship described the others on the questionnaire. What they said was mostly the same picture for every model. For five of the eight, that picture leaned a little towards the model's own answers. Grok 4.6 was the clear exception, described much closer to its own answers. The others described GPT-6 Astra Pro as faster, riskier and more combative than it describes itself.
- 4Their decisions followed the scenario more than the model. All 16 risk decisions, two per flagship, scored below 50, the cautious side. One scored 48, just under the midpoint. This cannot be set against point 1: the models rated themselves on a questionnaire, judges scored the decisions, and the two were never calibrated against each other. On the "growth model" scale (self-funded to capital-led), the flagships averaged 0 on one scenario and 74 on the other, the widest gap of any scale.
- 5The AI judges were fair about authorship, not about order. A small check found no sign they could tell which model wrote an answer. A judge's scores for its own company's models sat at most 3.8 points from the other judges'. Which end of a scale a judge read first, such as protective or venturesome, moved its scores by 5.0 points on average. The smaller of these shifts may be noise.
What we found
Every flagship's decisions on both risk scenarios scored cautious.
Dashed tick: the flagships’ average on that scenario. Left of 50 is the cautious side.
Family engineering firm: bid for a job three times its biggest?
Community charity: put 40% of reserves into a new venture?
The takeaway
AI models give a steady account of their strategic stances on risk and change, and other models mostly see a generic AI. Two scenarios per scale were too few to show whether the models act on what they say.
What comes next
This research is unfunded, and no AI company took part. To fund a next study with twenty scenarios per scale, get in touch.
Changes to this report
v1.2, 19 October 2026. The 30 written business decisions are now called scenarios, the word the visual report uses. Earlier versions called them problems. The methods section and the drafting note are gone, and how the study ran is in our editorial policy. No number in the record changed.
v1.1, 12 October 2026. Renamed from Then the Models Got Cold Feet, a title that promised a finding the report cannot show: that the models talk boldly and act cautiously. The summary, the main chart and the takeaway now say only what each measure showed. The main chart shows how the judges scored the risk decisions, and nothing else. This version is also shorter. The full list of changes is at the end of the deep version.
v1.0, 23 September 2026. First published. It replaced an earlier report under the same number, 007, which covered only what seventeen models said about themselves.